PitchPanel

Startup pitch feedbackPut your pitch in front of the panel

Paste a one-liner, an elevator pitch or the text of your deck. Five investor archetypes score it on ten criteria and tell you who would take the second meeting.

Try a sample

Write at least a sentence about what you do and for whom.

Who is on the panel

The Operator

Judges execution and team.

The Market Hawk

Judges market size and timing.

The Skeptic

Judges risks, defensibility and red flags.

The Product Nerd

Judges problem clarity, insight and differentiation.

The Numbers Person

Judges business model and traction evidence.

How the panel scores a pitch

Each judge is a set of typed questions sent to Jev, a model that answers with numbers rather than text. The judge's lens rides along with the pitch, so the same text gets read five different ways. All wording on the report comes from templates, not the model.

Ten criteria

  1. Problem clarity. How clearly does the pitch describe who has the problem and how much it hurts?
  2. Unique insight. How non-obvious and earned is the core insight behind this startup?
  3. Differentiation. How clearly does the product stand apart from the alternatives customers use today?
  4. Market size. How large and well identified is the market this startup can reach?
  5. Timing. How convincingly does the pitch explain why now is the moment for this?
  6. Team fit. How well suited is the founding team to this specific problem?
  7. Execution plan. How concrete and credible is the plan for building, selling and reaching the next milestone?
  8. Business model. How clear and attractive is the way this startup makes money?
  9. Traction evidence. How strong is the evidence that customers actually want this?
  10. Defensibility. How hard would it be for a well funded competitor to copy this?

A four step ladder

Every judge rates all ten on four steps. For problem clarity the ladder runs from "the problem is vague or not stated at all" to "the problem is sharp, urgent and backed by evidence that customers feel it".

Each judge weighs their lens

Criteria outside a judge's lens count once. The lens counts more.

  • The Operator counts team fit 3x, execution plan 3x, traction evidence 1.5x. A red flag costs up to 8 points.
  • The Market Hawk counts market size 3x, timing 3x. A red flag costs up to 8 points.
  • The Skeptic counts differentiation 2x, traction evidence 1.5x, defensibility 3x. A red flag costs up to 18 points.
  • The Product Nerd counts problem clarity 3x, unique insight 3x, differentiation 3x. A red flag costs up to 8 points.
  • The Numbers Person counts business model 3x, traction evidence 3x. A red flag costs up to 8 points.

In, maybe or pass

A judge is in at 60 or more with at least a 60% chance of a second meeting, a pass under 40 or under a 35% chance, and a maybe otherwise. The panel is in when three judges are in and a pass when three pass. Any criterion the panel averages under 50 becomes a gap, with advice written for that criterion.

Your pitch is sent to the Jev model from TypeSafe to be scored. The server does not save it. Saved pitches and reports stay in this browser's local storage, and the server only keeps a short-lived request count per IP address to rate limit the free panels.

Built by Sahil ChalkeSource code on GitHub

How the panel scores a pitch

Each of the five judges is a set of typed questions sent to Jev, a model that answers with numbers rather than text. The judge's lens rides along in the state, so the same pitch gets read five different ways.

Every judge rates all ten criteria on a four step ladder, from "not there" to "strong". Criteria in the judge's lens count three times as much. A red flag lowers the score, and the Skeptic punishes it hardest.

A judge is in at 60 or more with at least a 60% chance of a second meeting, a pass under 40 or under 35%, and a maybe otherwise. Any criterion the panel averages under 50 becomes a gap, with advice written for that criterion. All wording on the page comes from templates, not the model.

The Operator

Weighs team fit, execution plan, traction evidence

The Market Hawk

Weighs market size, timing

The Skeptic

Weighs differentiation, traction evidence, defensibility

The Product Nerd

Weighs problem clarity, unique insight, differentiation

The Numbers Person

Weighs business model, traction evidence

Pitches are saved only in this browser, in local storage.